David Lynch is best known for making bizarre films, and that sneaks into The Elephant Man just a bit, with some dreamlike imagery involving the death of the titular character's mother. But for the most part he plays things straight, telling the simple human story of an extremely deformed man who grew up in Victorian England. You can see why Lynch would be attracted to the project, though he doesn't go too wild with it; the appearance of John Merrick is close to but actually slightly less grotesque than that of the real Joseph Merrick, partially due to the limits of what makeup can do. Still, it's an accurate enough depiction of his story, not intended to disturb but more to inspire. Merrick's story is ultimately a sad one, but it's told with grace and skill that seems honest without being exploitative.
Anthony Hopkins is a doctor who discovers Merrick being shown as the elephant man in a carnival freak show and brings him back to his hospital for study. At first he seems only interested in the scientific advancements and attention that can be gotten from such an unheard of collection of deformities, but he soon learns that Merrick is more intelligent than initially assumed and develops a friendship with him. There are a couple barriers that get thrown in their way - others at the hospital are not keen on having an incurable case taking up a room, and other people aren't quite so kind to someone with such an appearance. There's ultimately a peaceful resolution for the characters, and the film ends with a particularly beautiful and well-considered sequence. The black and white works well for the story, making it easier to buy Merrick's appearance and generally the cinematography sells the setting smartly. Hopkins is very good, and John Hurt does an excellent job of humanizing Merrick despite working in pretty difficult conditions. There are only a few glimpses of what makes Lynch a unique filmmaker, but the movie doesn't really need his brand of weirdness to be good.
Sunday, February 6, 2011
The Elephant Man
Thursday, February 3, 2011
Ratatouille
I have finally seen every full length Pixar film that people actually seem to like. Ratatouille was one of the better ones, sliding nicely into my favorites with The Incredibles, Wall-E, and Toy Story 3. Like the first one it was directed by Brad Bird, who also did the excellent The Iron Giant before joining America's best animation studio. He's moving on now to live action with the next Mission: Impossible, and it will be interesting to see how his great storytelling talents survive the transition to huge budgets and name brand actors. Ratatouille does everything that Pixar is good at extremely well, and except for a couple hiccups here and there is really just a great movie from start to finish.
A lot of Pixar stories can be boiled down to "The Secret Lives of _____", and it's not inaccurate to use that formula here by filling in the blank with rats. The movie portrays them as more or less the creatures we know them, except with intelligence enough to fully understand English and grasp how they're regarded by humans. They're still mostly content to eat garbage and avoid direct contact, but due to an advanced sense of smell and taste Remy, played by Patton Oswalt, has developed an appreciation for human cooking, and the food of a famed French chef who claims that "anyone can cook" in particular. After his family is forced to leave their home he winds up in Paris, in the kitchen of the very same chef he admires, two years after his death. Through an unlikely but entertaining series of events he ends up helping a hapless but likable garbage boy become a successful cook in the restaurant, and even more unlikely he turns out to be the cook's heir, and that's where the real story begins.
The highlight of the film is the animation, which is both technically impeccable and marvelously kinetic and fun to look at. The animation of the rats is lifelike, to a creepy extent when there are swarms of them on the screen, and the humans are wonderfully characterized through unique mannerisms as well. The absolute best bits are whenever Remy is tugging on the garbage boy's hair to trigger his muscles and perform the steps of cooking without being seen, an idea that is hilariously absurd and even more hilariously animated. It's just the essence of pure physical comedy, perfect in how it doesn't need dialogue even while the boy's meek excuses for his awkward actions accentuate the humor. The relationship between them is a really interesting one, Remy unable to actually speak to humans but able to get his points across with squeaks and gestures. There's plenty of talent to go around with the voices, including well-known comedians, great actors like Ian Holm and Peter O'Toole, and some solid work by people you've never heard of.
If I had an issue with the movie, it's that a large part of the conflict that makes up the meat of the plot in the later stages isn't really justified in the movie. A rift forms between the human and rat leads, and there's no real reason for it, especially since the apparent cause is in complete opposition with what they seemed to want only a few scenes earlier. The movie needed something to happen, and they just sort of swept the need of actually having it make sense under the rug. It doesn't do to much to damage the rest of the movie though, which while not as deeply emotional as the most recent Pixar outfit, is still incredibly entertaining work. It's amazing how an action sequence featuring a rodent trying to get through a window in a busy kitchen can be more exciting than live action stuff that can cost millions to film. I guess I'll watch Cars some time and hope it's at least a fraction as compelling as stuff like this.
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Woman in the Dunes
One of the best parts about this whole watch-a-ton-of-classic-films project is getting to see the work of some Japanese filmmakers who aren't Akira Kurosawa. This movie actually got nominated for the Best Director Oscar when it eventually came out in America, which shows how captivating it can be despite its simple story and slow pace. I'm wondering whether I should actually explain what the premise is, because I'm not sure whether the tension of the opening scenes would be greater if you were wondering along with the protagonist about what was happening or just waiting for him to figure it out. Suffice it to say, a teacher visits an area rich in sand to study its bugs, but misses the bus home and ends up stuck in a house surrounded by walls of sand on all sides with a widowed woman.
He struggles with his captivity at first, but over time becomes torn between his desire to return home and his growing feelings towards the woman. It's a remarkably sensual film for 1964, but in a weird way; the two never seem to really fully understand what they are to each other, and lots of time is spent with weird images like close-ups of skin covered in grains of sand. But while it's a very stately film completely filled with existentialist ideas, it's a lot more watchable than it seems like it might be. They really pull off quite a bit with two actors, a house, and a ton of sand. Eventually the story shifts away from the romantic aspect, as the main character finds more things than just the woman keeping him in the house, constantly digging to prevent the house from getting buried. I found the ending odd, because it concluded the man's story in an unsettling and appropriate way for the movie's tone, but it raises other questions to get there that it doesn't bother getting to. Still, the film accomplishes what it intends, and never compromises itself for any reason.
Tuesday, February 1, 2011
Come and See
Come and See is the ultimate horrors of war film. Without being overly bloody or explicit in general about its content, it paints an absolutely devastating and harrowing picture of the Nazi invasion of the Byelorussian part of the Soviet Union during World War II. It stars a young man, barely out of his preteen years, who joins an army unit after finding a rifle buried in the ground near his home. He is left behind after they march out, and after losing his hearing in a bombing, he returns home with a strange girl only to find his village has been wiped out. They find some survivors of various raids, and he goes off with some men for supplies before eventually coming face to face with the soldiers that have been ravaging his country.
Come and See was the last film director Elem Klimov made, and you can see how it would be someone's final statement as an artist. It at times seems sensationalistic, with many scenes of the young main actor just gaping or cringing in absolute horror as the worst stuff he's ever seen constantly happens around him. But no single moment is over the top - it's just that's he's constantly being exposed to the worst things that can happen when your homeland is overrun by an unsympathetic force. There's eventually a point where some of the Russians finally have an upper hand on some Nazis, and you've just been so beaten down by the preceding hours of the movie that you don't even want to see them take revenge. It's very powerful film making. Long takes are used extensively to increase the sense of reality, and some of the images are unforgettable despite the seeming lack of budget for extravagant set ups. The spectacular climactic sequence is made up almost entirely of well-edited found footage, and it's effective as anything that could have been done with original work. It's hard to say I loved a movie that's so difficult at times to look at, but as I said before, it's the best example I've seen of portraying the truth about war's worst elements.